The Ultimate Guide to Portland, Maine's Best Lobster Rolls - Holiday Inn by the Bay

Press & News

The Ultimate Guide to Portland, Maine’s Best Lobster Rolls

When you think of Portland, Maine, there’s one culinary delight that stands out above all others – the lobster roll! This iconic New England dish has found its true home along the shores of Casco Bay, and today, we’re taking you on a mouthwatering journey to discover the best lobster rolls this vibrant coastal city has to offer.

Highroller Lobster Co

highroller lobster co lobster roll

Highroller Lobster Co / photo via Yelp

Highroller Lobster Co is a local favorite, known for its inventive twists on the classic lobster roll. Their Lobster Grilled Cheese is a must-try, featuring succulent lobster meat filled with gooey cheese. It’s comfort food at its finest, served in a friendly and upbeat atmosphere.

Portland Lobster Company

portland lobster co lobster rolls with view of the harbor

Portland Lobster Company / photo via Tripadvisor

For a quintessential lobster roll experience by the water, head to Portland Lobster Company. Their lobster roll is brimming with generous chunks of freshly caught lobster meat, lightly dressed in mayo, and nestled in a toasted roll. Enjoy it on their spacious outdoor deck with panoramic views of the harbor.

Eventide Oyster Company

eventide oyster co lobster rolls

Eventide Oyster Company / photo via Google

Eventide Oyster Company offers a lobster roll that’s nothing short of extraordinary. They serve it on a Chinese-style steamed bun with brown butter sauce, giving it a unique and unforgettable flavor profile. It’s a culinary adventure you won’t want to miss.

The Lobster Shack at Two Lights

the lobster shack at two lights lobster roll with ocean in background

The Lobster Shack at Two Lights / photo via Tripadvisor

Perched on the rocky coast with breathtaking ocean views, The Lobster Shack at Two Lights is a classic lobster shack experience. Their lobster rolls are renowned for their simplicity: fresh lobster meat, a dollop of mayo, and a sprinkle of salt and pepper, all served in a buttered, grilled bun.

Bite Into Maine

bite into maine lobster rolls with lighthouse in the background

Bite Into Maine / photo via FoodTrux

Bite Into Maine is known for its variety of lobster rolls, each representing a different part of Maine. Whether you choose the classic Maine-style, the Connecticut-style with warm butter, or the coleslaw-filled “Picnic,” you’ll be treated to lobster perfection with a creative twist.

Becky’s Diner

beckys diner lobster roll

Becky’s Diner / photo via Yelp

A beloved local institution, Becky’s Diner serves up a lobster roll that’s as hearty as it is delicious. Their rolls are loaded with tender lobster meat and a light mayo-based dressing, all served in a no-nonsense, classic diner setting. Becky’s Diner has garnered nationwide recognition for its delectable seafood, and you might just recognize it from its appearance on the popular TV show “Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives.”

Luke’s Lobster

lukes lobster lobster rolls

Luke’s Lobster / photo via Tripadvisor

Luke’s Lobster is famous for its commitment to sustainability and quality. Their lobster roll features sweet, claw and knuckle meat served chilled in a buttered, split-top bun. It’s simple, fresh, and absolutely delightful.

The Porthole Restaurant & Pub

the porthole lobster roll

The Porthole / photo via Facebook

The Porthole is an iconic waterfront spot offering lobster rolls with a generous helping of lobster meat, lightly coated in mayo and seasoned to perfection. Pair it with a cold local beer while watching boats drift by in the harbor.

J’s Oyster

js oyster lobster roll and view of the harbor

J’s Oyster / photo via Yelp

J’s Oyster is a local hangout known for its laid-back atmosphere and seafood dishes. Their lobster roll is a no-fuss, traditional delight, showcasing the essence of Maine’s lobster culture.

Susan’s Fish-n-Chips

susans fish and chips lobster roll

Susan’s Fish-n-Chips / photo via Tripadvisor

For a lobster roll that won’t break the bank, Susan’s Fish-n-Chips delivers affordability without compromising on quality. Their lobster rolls are straightforward and delicious, making them an excellent choice for a quick and satisfying meal.

Whether you’re a seafood enthusiast or just passing through, exploring Portland’s lobster rolls is a culinary adventure that’s sure to leave your taste buds dancing. Each of these restaurants offers a unique take on this classic dish, making it hard to pick a favorite. So, why not embark on a lobster roll tasting tour and savor the flavors of Portland, Maine, one delicious bite at a time?

Back to Posts